ALL STYLES + DISENGAGING

3-8 people

Facilitator input needed – The President can consult with a facilitator on how to maximise participation in this exercise.

120 minutes

 

  • Preparation: 15 minutes
  • Group Exercise: 30 minutes
  • Review: 1 hour
  • Exercise High Speed Repeat and Review: 15 minutes

Instructions

Objective

 

This exercise is an opportunity to practise in a complex situation that includes hierarchical relationships.

 

Preparation

 

Four people are needed to play the following roles:

  • President of the company
  • Vice-president for manufacturing
  • Vice-president for Sales
  • Vice-president for Human resources

If there are only three people available for this exercise, eliminate the role of Vice-president for Human Resources.

If there are five people who wish to participate two people can take the role of President and work together to plan their approach, then operate as a tag team with one person playing the role of President for the first half of the meeting before handing over to the second person.

This approach can be used for all roles in the meeting according to numbers.

The facilitator will be responsible for timing and recording the meeting.

 

Exercise

 

1. Choose the role you wish to play then read the Information Known To All Parties and the information sheet for your role. Study the specific role so that it can be played without referring to the written material. Do not read the other roles.

2. The President(s) should have a brief consultation with the facilitator before they prepare for the meeting.

3. Prepare for the meeting. Decide on your Influence Objective and choose the Influence Style(s) that you want to practise. Take some time to plan your approach. If you are working as a pair think about how you will align your approach.

4. Run the meeting. If working as a pair the group should pause after 15 minutes to swap over. No conferring! Each pair can request one timeout for a max 2-minute conference if required.

5. Review. The facilitator will manage the review process during which you will:

  • Share your Influence Objective and your Practice Style(s)
  • Share feedback on how successful people were in achieving their objectives and practicing the Styles.
  • Review parts of the recording and look for missed opportunities and ways in which you might have been more effective.

6. High speed exercise

Modify your approach based on the review session. Focus on the opening of the meeting. Make sure everyone has an opportunity to participate.

7. Take time to record useful feedback and learning in your Journal (5 minutes)

Information known to all parties

Expando, Inc. produces a variety of tubular knit products. Founded in 1938, the company flourished for two decades as a manufacturer of elastic tubes or sheaths that were used in the construction of women’s undergarments. In the 1960s, changes in women’s fashions drastically reduced the market for these items. During this period, Expando’s sales were off by 75 percent, and the company was forced to sell all but one of its manufacturing units. During the 1970s, Expando continued to manufacture and sell their undergarment stock, but occasionally filled special orders from manufacturers of bathing suits, athletic equipment, aerobics costumes, athletic supporters, and so on. The company experienced little growth during this time, operating at about a break-even point.

In recent years, the rapid growth in popularity of health and fitness activities has been accompanied by the rise of speciality clothing manufacturers catering to that industry. These clothing producers have shown a steadily increasing demand for stretch fabrics. However, rapid technological developments in synthetic fibres and manufacturing processes, plus strong competition from larger companies, have presented problems for smaller companies such as Expando in responding to this new market.

Expando’s inability to compete for large volume business has made it necessary to depend increasingly on speciality orders from small clothing manufacturers. Although per-unit profit margin on such orders is acceptable, this kind of business requires flexibility and speed in changing manufacturing procedures, as well as an alert and aggressive sales force to obtain orders. Similarly, ingenuity in product development and production are essential for meeting competition, providing for efficient changeover from one order or product to another, and achieving quick solutions to a variety of complex production problems. In addition, it is necessary for the production supervisors and operators to adapt to frequent changes in job specifications and procedures, without undue amounts of training time or job dissatisfaction.

Because Expando management was not able to adapt to these changing conditions, something had to be done. Three years ago, the president of the company reached the mandatory retirement age and was replaced. Within a year, all senior executive positions had been filled with new faces.

A brief biography, known by all parties, of each of the senior executives:

President

Forty-eight years old; has been with the company 12 years, first as an accountant, then as controller for five years; promoted to president three years ago; college graduate majoring in accounting; a certified public accountant.

Vice-President, Manufacturing

Background in mechanical engineering; hired into the company as a management trainee, and was plant manager before promotion to vice-president two years ago; 45 years old.

Vice-President, Sales

Joined Expando five years ago as sales manager; previously was assistant sales manager for a division of a large textile manufacturer; recruited by Expando to widen the market for company products, but not given much support by former sales vice-president; has worked in sales since getting bachelor’s degree in business administration; is 46 years old and has been in present position for two years.

Vice-President, Human Resources

Thirty-nine years old; joined the personnel office at largest Expando knitting mill before it was sold; led both the recruiting and the training and development effort at company’s last remaining plant; eight years ago was brought to headquarters as personnel director, and was promoted to vice-president nearly three years ago.

Information known only to President

You are president of Expando, Inc., and have held this position for the last three years.

One of the most difficult problems you have dealt with since you became president is whether or not to expand operations. There are conflicting views on the matter within the company and among your close business associates. Those who are opposed to expansion contend that real estate and building values are now seriously inflated, and the costs of new equipment are extremely high. Also, they argue that the speciality clothing industry is highly sensitive to economic downturns and style changes. Since company financial reserves are low, you would have to obtain the funds necessary for expansion through stock sales or mortgage loans, and the present financial condition of the company is not advantageous for such financing.

There are others who favour immediate expansion. All of them tend to see the situation in terms of their own particular area of the business, and none are in a position to see the big picture. Nevertheless, in casual discussions of the matter these advocates have presented some impressive facts and arguments for establishing a new manufacturing facility. First, they argue that your present remaining plant is not adaptable to modern production methods. In the past it has been necessary to turn down two or three large orders because of capacity insufficient to meet specified production deadlines. Finally, these people contend that lack of growth is damaging morale and good employees are becoming discouraged and leaving for larger or faster-growing companies where opportunities are greater.

Over the past several months, you have tried to keep an open mind to both points of view. Despite the risks, you were becoming convinced that, on a long-term basis, expansion was the better course to follow. You have been making progress in getting the company profitable, even though it is a slow, uphill struggle.

Despite your best efforts and your feeling of progress, the board of directors informed you yesterday afternoon that they had voted to give you one more year in which to show some results or else resign. You had known previously that certain members of the board were becoming impatient, but this action came as a real shock to you. You are convinced that the board is not going to change its mind. Clearly, expansion is out of the question if results have to be shown within a year. It would take longer than that to make the necessary financial arrangements, and to construct a new mill. The only possible course of action is to play it safe and hope for the best. With a few good breaks and strict “belt tightening” throughout the organisation, you might achieve the desired results within the deadline set by the board.

Since immediate expansion is no longer possible, you must inform your key executives and motivate them to work with you to improve short-term results. As a first step, you have called a meeting of your three vice- presidents for 3:00 p.m. You know that if you tell them the board’s ultimatum they will waste energy talking about how to reverse the board’s decision. You have decided not to tell them about the board’s action, and instead to take personal responsibility for the decision not to expand. During the meeting, you would like to gain the cooperation of your vice presidents in finding ways to increase productivity and cut costs, so that you can achieve the results the board expects in the time they have given you.

  • Influence Objective(s)
  • Influence Style or Behaviour you intend to practise
  • Core Style Statement
Information known only to Vice-President, Manufacturing

You are the vice-president in charge of manufacturing for Expando, Inc. When you moved into this job from plant manager, two years ago, you had high hopes of streamlining operations, and at this point you have accomplished a great deal. For years, the previous management had refused to spend money on manufacturing facilities, and instead followed a penny-pinching practice of patching and fixing, making you do the best you could with inferior, outmoded facilities and equipment.

Through your influence with the new president, you have been able to make a number of changes in layout and methods. By careful shopping around, you have been able to get good buys on several pieces of secondhand but still fairly modern equipment. In addition, you have established a product-testing laboratory. This laboratory is required for the company to compete with larger organisations which have large development staffs. The laboratory has been very helpful in bringing out new products and in working out designs which help simplify manufacturing. The company has been slow getting “back on its feet,” but you have contributed greatly by managing to lower manufacturing costs.

However, you have gone about as far as you can in this direction. What the company needs now is a new facility. The present building was satisfactory for its purpose 30 years ago, but new and larger machinery, as well as government regulations, require more efficient space with better lighting and ventilation. The layout of the present building is awkward for moving products through the manufacturing cycle, which creates lots of needless delay in changeovers resulting from incoming new orders. Also, the current building is costly to operate, and the construction is not strong enough to support some of the new heavy machinery on the upper floors, where it ought to be located.

Repeatedly, you have urged the president to expand into a new, single-story building and purchase new machinery. You have always gotten a fair hearing, but have never yet gotten a firm commitment. The president is a good accountant, but does not know the manufacturing end of the business very well. On the issue of expansion, the president seems to be very undecided. Perhaps this is because, as controller, the current president merely advised and did not have to make final decisions. Now, on the “firing line,” the president does seem to have difficulty reaching such important decisions. You have given the best advice you can, and you want to help move things along faster, but the president has to make the decision to expand. Without expansion, the company will no longer be able to meet competition.

The president has called a meeting with you and the other two vice-presidents. You are not sure what the president wishes to talk about, but you hope to get a final decision to go ahead with the new building. Almost anything would be an improvement over the one you have now.

  • Influence Objective(s)
  • Influence Style or Behaviour you intend to practise
  • Core Style Statement
Information known only to Vice-President, Sales

You are vice-president in charge of sales, and came to Expando, Inc. five years ago. Previously, you were the assistant sales manager of a division of one of the larger textile manufacturing companies. Taking on the vice- presidency of sales at Expando meant quite an increase in salary and responsibility, and it seemed to you that here was a real opportunity to do a good job and make a name for yourself.

Five years ago, the company had no real sales organisation and was losing ground rapidly to competition. Therefore, one of your first moves was to begin “building from the ground up,” in an effort to recapture the market and expand further. This process took a lot of work, and you had to struggle to get the old management to accept your ideas. Now, Expando has sales offices in most of the principal eastern cities, where Expando products are in demand by manufacturers. You have also built up a fairly strong sales organisation.

The change of management three years ago had its advantages for you, since the new president has given you more freedom to operate than you previously had. In some ways, the president is doing a fair job, but seems to you rather unimaginative. Your ideas always get a fair hearing but, in the end, the president seems to be wary of new promotional campaigns. During the past two years, the president has deflated some of your best promotional ideas by simply delaying action on them until it was too late. For example, one idea you have been advocating is an expansion of manufacturing facilities. This would give you a big advantage: in the past year you have lost several big orders when the manufacturing vice-president said the company could not possibly meet the deadline set by the customer. You are willing to grant that the deadlines may have been unreasonable in one or two instances. However, it has begun to seem to you that manufacturing is not fast enough to make the necessary changeovers. Since the president refuses to push, you have begun to think that the manufacturing vice-president is the president’s favourite. But you believe that with a modern manufacturing facility there would be no more excuses, and you could take advantage of big orders when they become available.

Also, it would help a lot if those people in charge of the testing laboratory would get to work. Although they have been set up for two years now, and although your sales people have been showering them with ideas for new products, they have not shown any progress. A small company like Expando frequently must have new and better products in order to compete for new markets. With new and innovative products, newspapers and trade journals give you a lot of free publicity, and that helps your sales people get “a foot in the door” of potential new customers. The main concern, however, is to get a new manufacturing facility so that larger orders can be handled. Turning down the big ones, as you have had to do several times in the past, is what really hurts, and it demoralises your sales force.

The president has been receptive enough to your arguments for expansion, and there has been evidence lately of some readiness to take action. Today there is a meeting in the president’s office, with you and the other two vice-presidents. Apparently, the president is about to announce plans for the new facility.

  • Influence Objective(s)
  • Influence Style or Behaviour you intend to practise
  • Core Style Statement
Information known only to Vice-President, Human Resources

You are vice-president in charge of human resources at Expando, Inc., and you have held this position since you moved up from the job of personnel director nearly three years ago. All of the usual personnel services are handled through your office, including recruiting, hiring, compensation, labour relations, and training and development. You have set up your office to meet three major priorities. One is to prevent as many personnel problems as possible, and to assist the supervisors with those that do arise. Second, you advise the president on personnel matters. Finally, you are responsible for maintaining a competent work force—people who get along well with each other and do a good job.

As personnel director, you were able to initiate an individualised program of training and work experiences for promising young college recruits. Even though the conservatism of the previous management stymied the progress of these newly hired professionals in many ways, you were able to obtain a few good people each year. When the reorganisation took place three years ago, a considerable number of these people were able to move up a notch. In turn, this left a number of vacancies at the trainee level which you were able to fill by recruiting at the universities. However, now you are faced again with the same problem you had previously: the company is not growing, and many of the individuals you brought in at the time of the reorganisation are now ready to move up, and they are becoming impatient. Further, you cannot offer much promise to new college graduates. At present, there just is no place for them to move up in the company – and there will not be, unless the company expands its operations.

Meanwhile, some of your best recruits are disheartened and are leaving. Competing companies are luring them away, one by one. If this is allowed to continue, the management at the middle and lower levels will become second-rate within a few years. Unless the company can offer good people some inducements to stay, there will be crippling losses in many of the key positions. The company simply cannot afford such losses if it is to remain competitive. From your perspective, expansion is absolutely essential if the company is to keep its most promising personnel.

The president has called a meeting, and all three vice-presidents will be attending. It looks like the president may be ready to announce plans for the new manufacturing facility. Unless there is some such development, it will be hopeless to try to keep your best people.

  • Influence Objective(s)
  • Influence Style or Behaviour you intend to practise
  • Core Style Statement
Information known only to Consultant

The president of Expando, Inc. has invited you to attend a meeting with the vice presidents of manufacturing, sales, and human resources. Your main responsibilities for this meeting will be to facilitate the discussion of the agenda, and assist the group in reaching a productive agreement. The president has provided you with a written description of the history and current position of the company, which includes the purpose of the meeting. You have not received any additional information about how the president intends to run the meeting.

Before the meeting starts, you should confer with the president to decide what you are expected to do during the meeting itself. After all, you will be there at the president’s invitation. You have not yet met any of the vice- presidents personally, although you know that they are aware the president has asked you to attend. Expando is the newest client in your practice, and one of the biggest. You have served the company on various assignments over the past year. You want to do the best job that you can for the president but you also want to help find the best solution for the company. Also, you are concerned about the bigger picture and your role in it. If the president is unable to retain control of the company and ends up leaving, you would like to be able to stay on as an important outside resource.

  • Influence Objective(s)
  • Influence Style or Behaviour you intend to practise
  • Core Style Statement